Between Pride and Despair
Stories of Queensland’s Great Barrier Reef and Wet Tropics Rainforests
Edited by
Kerrie Foxwell-Norton [+–]
Griffith University
Kerrie Foxwell-Norton lectures in Journalism, Media and Communication. Her research interests focus upon environmental communication, with a special interest in coastal and marine communities and their environments. Kerrie has specific expertise in community based research and engagement, exploring links between communication and community therein.
She leads the ‘Motivation’ theme within the Griffith Climate Action Beacon, a strategic university wide research initiative. She is Co-Chair of the Environment, Science and Risk Working Group and a member of the Environmental Impact Committee for the International Association of Communication and Media Research. She is also the Co-Chair of the Queensland Chapter for the Australian Coastal Society and Associate Editor (Environment) for Queensland Review.
Iain McCalman [+–]
Australian Catholic University
Professor Iain Duncan McCalman, AO, FRHistS, FASSA, FAHA, FRSN was born in Malawi, Africa, schooled in Zimbabwe, and earned his BA, MA and PhD in Melbourne and Canberra, Australia. He recently retired from a position as Research Professor of History and Co-Director of the Sydney Environment Institute at the University of Sydney. He has held many Visiting Research Fellowships in Britain and the United States, including at All Souls and Oriel Colleges, Oxford, Princeton,New Jersey, and as a Mellon Visiting Professor at the California Institute of Technology, Pasadena.
Iain is a Fellow and former President of the Australian Academy of the Humanities, and a Fellow of three other Learned Academies in Australia and Britain, and is a Professor Emeritus of the University of Sydney and the Australian National University.
The latest special issue of Queensland Review reflects on Queensland’s Great Barrier Reef and Wet Tropics Rainforests, exploring the relationships between these at-risk ecosystems and people and places both nearby and further afield. The issue interweaves personal reflections with scholarly articles, showcasing the broader humanity of environmental care and aiming to dilute the arbitrary divisions between ourselves and nature.
Table of Contents
Introduction
Between Pride and Despair: Stories of Queensland’s Great Barrier Reef and Wet Tropics Rainforests 77-79
Australian Catholic University
Professor Iain Duncan McCalman, AO, FRHistS, FASSA, FAHA, FRSN was born in Malawi, Africa, schooled in Zimbabwe, and earned his BA, MA and PhD in Melbourne and Canberra, Australia. He recently retired from a position as Research Professor of History and Co-Director of the Sydney Environment Institute at the University of Sydney. He has held many Visiting Research Fellowships in Britain and the United States, including at All Souls and Oriel Colleges, Oxford, Princeton,New Jersey, and as a Mellon Visiting Professor at the California Institute of Technology, Pasadena.
Iain is a Fellow and former President of the Australian Academy of the Humanities, and a Fellow of three other Learned Academies in Australia and Britain, and is a Professor Emeritus of the University of Sydney and the Australian National University.
Griffith University
Kerrie Foxwell-Norton lectures in Journalism, Media and Communication. Her research interests focus upon environmental communication, with a special interest in coastal and marine communities and their environments. Kerrie has specific expertise in community based research and engagement, exploring links between communication and community therein.
She leads the ‘Motivation’ theme within the Griffith Climate Action Beacon, a strategic university wide research initiative. She is Co-Chair of the Environment, Science and Risk Working Group and a member of the Environmental Impact Committee for the International Association of Communication and Media Research. She is also the Co-Chair of the Queensland Chapter for the Australian Coastal Society and Associate Editor (Environment) for Queensland Review.
Tourism Reef Advisory Committee / Reef 2050 Advisory Committee for the Great Barrier Reef
Chrissy Grant is an Aboriginal (Eastern Kuku Yalanji) and Torres Strait Islander
(Mualgal from Moa Island) Elder. She has worked on GBRMPA projects, including
the Strong Peoples —– Strong Country Framework, and is a Member of the
Tourism Reef Advisory Committee and the Reef 2050 Advisory Committee for
the Great Barrier Reef.
(Mualgal from Moa Island) Elder. She has worked on GBRMPA projects, including
the Strong Peoples —– Strong Country Framework, and is a Member of the
Tourism Reef Advisory Committee and the Reef 2050 Advisory Committee for
the Great Barrier Reef.
Personal reflections from Chrissy Grant, an Aboriginal (Eastern Kuku Yalanji). As First Nations people with deep connections to Far North Queensland ‘Country’, their reflections demonstrate the enduring power of their cultural science and practice, and how these have also sometimes become enmeshed with Western systems of knowledge and management.
Chapter 1
Australian Catholic University
Killian Quigley is a research fellow at the Institute for Humanities and Social Sciences, Australian Catholic University and honorary postdoctoral fellow at the Sydney Environment Institute, University of Sydney. He is the co-editor, with Margaret Cohen, of The Aesthetics of the Undersea and author of the forthcoming Reading Underwater Wreckage: An Encrusting Ocean. His research is available, now or imminently, from Environmental Humanities, Green Letters, A Cultural History of the Sea in the Age of Enlightenment, Maritime Animals: Ships, Species, Stories and elsewhere. He is an associate member of the Oceanic Humanities for the Global South research network.
The Great Barrier Reef has been bleaching yet again. If the Anthropocene had a colour table, bleached coral would hold an especially recognizable place within it. By some lights, chromatic behaviour — and chromatic disaster — are best apprehended as secondary qualities, as spectacles that offer to point the discerning observer beyond the tokens of human sense and toward an object’s (or ecosystem’s) essential properties. This article asks whether it is possible, and ethically viable, to recognise corallian colour practice as having meaning in and of itself. I argue that we should recognise coral colourism as the irreducibly relational comportment of species, sunlight, salt water, sediment and so on. Contrary to some influential views, the Reef’s performances are not simply constructed by the fantasies of human spectators, but by stimulating human sensoria, they do hail us as participants in the chromatic field. Reckoning the loss of hue as a discrete catastrophe might therefore generate tools for articulating value in a manner that is not strictly constructivist, naively scientistic or reactionarily idealistic. Caring for the Reef may be, not first of all but not least of all, a caring for colour — a caring against chromatic disappearance and a caring towards chromatic repair.
Chapter 2
University at Buffalo, State University of New York
Irus Braverman is Professor of Law and Adjunct Professor of Geography at the University at Buffalo, State University of New York. Her books include Zooland: The Institution of Captivity (2012), Wild Life: The Institution of Nature (2015) and Coral Whisperers: Scientists on the Brink (2018).
Chapter 3
University of Sydney
Ann Elias is Professor of Art History and Visual Culture at the University of Sydney. Research interests include camouflage as a military, social and aesthetic phenomenon; flowers and their cultural history; and coral reef imagery of the underwater realm. Books include Camouflage Australia: Art, Nature, Science and War (2011), Useless Beauty: Flowers and Australian Art (2015) and Coral Empire (2019). She is a Research Affiliate with the Sydney Environment Institute. Research in progress asks how the underwater of Sydney Harbour relates to Australian, Pacific and world social histories.
In the early twentieth century, great delight in the unique tropical beauty of the Great Barrier Reef, coupled with an opportunistic spirit for commercial development, inspired the commission of eye-catching posters and advertisements by Australian tourist organisations. The aim of this article is to discuss a pictorial device that developed alongside the rise of modern tourist advertising images of Great Barrier Reef – a split-level viewpoint that approximates the effect of looking at the Reef through the glass sides of an aquarium. Building on my earlier research published in 2019 on wildlife photography and the construction of the Great Barrier Reef as a modern visual spectacle, and combining art history with environmental history, this article also turns to coloured advertising lithographs. It argues that split-level visualisations separate human from non-human and elevate the idea of human superiority. With the Great Barrier Reef facing unprecedented ecological pressures, the historical images at the centre of this article are instructive for understanding the deleterious effects of anthropogenic impact, as well as early twentieth-century attitudes towards human–non-human relations.
Chapter 4
Queensland Museum
Carden Wallace AM is an Australian scientist who was the curator/director of the Museum of Tropical Queensland from 1987 to 2003. She is an expert on corals, having written a ‘revision of the Genus Acropora’. Wallace was part of a team that discovered mass spawning of coral in 1984. She is Emeritus Principal Scientist at the Queensland Museum.
Chapter 5
Great Barrier Reef World Heritage: Nature in Danger [+–] 118-129
University of Southern Queensland
Celmara Pocock is the Director of the Centre for Heritage and Culture and Associate Professor of Anthropology and Heritage Studies at the University of Southern Queensland. She is a leading heritage scholar with interests in social significance and community heritage, including Indigenous heritage, aesthetics and senses of place, storytelling and emotion, and the intersections between heritage and tourism. Her monograph Visitor Encounters with the Great Barrier Reef: Aesthetics, Heritage, and the Senses was published by Routledge in 2020.
The Great Barrier Reef is inscribed on the World Heritage List for its natural values, including an abundance of marine life and extraordinary aesthetic qualities. These and the enormous scale of the Reef make it unique and a place of ‘Outstanding Universal Value’. In the twentieth century, protection of the Great Barrier Reef shifted from limiting mechanical and physical impacts on coral reefs to managing agricultural runoff from adjacent mainland to minimise environmental impacts. By the early twenty-first century, it was apparent that threats to the Great Barrier Reef were no longer a local issue. Global warming, more frequent extreme weather events and increased ocean temperatures have destroyed vast swathes of coral reefs. Conservation scientists have begun trialling radical new methods of reseeding areas of bleached coral and creating more resilient coral species. The future of the Great Barrier Reef may depend on genetically engineered corals, and reefs that are seeded, weeded and cultured. This article asks whether the Great Barrier Reef can remain a natural World Heritage site or whether it might become World Heritage in Danger as its naturalness is questioned.
Chapter 6
Marine Ecosystem Policy Advisors
Diane Tarte is Director of Marine Ecosystem Policy Advisors, providing advice on policy and programs addressing research and management of marine, coastal and catchment areas. Since the late 1970s, Diane has been involved in advocating for protection of the Great Barrier Reef and has undertaken field inventory work on Reef islands and cays, and Queensland coastal tidal wetland systems.
Chapter 7
Coal versus Coral: Australian Climate Change Politics sees the Great Barrier Reef in Court [+–] 132-146
University of Tasmania
Dr Claire Konkes is a Senior Lecturer and Head of Discipline at The Media School, University of Tasmania. Her research continues to explore the role of media, especially news media, in the development of policy and law, especially in relation to gendered violence and the environment.
Dr Cynthia Nixon has a bachelor’s degree in Environmental Engineering, a Master’s in Environmental Law and a PhD in Media. Her research has focused on the intersection of strategic communication, litigation, media, and activism. She has worked for over 15 years in the energy and paper industries and is currently a consultant working to improve the sustainability of organisations by improving their environmental, social and governance (ESG) performance. Cynthia’s current focus is supporting the rapidly growing renewable energy sector as the world transitions to a cleaner energy landscape.
University of Tasmania
Professor Libby Lester is Director of the Institute for Social Change and Professor of Journalism, Media and Communications at the University of Tasmania, Australia. She works to understand the place of public debate in local and global decision-making, and her research on environmental communication and conflict is published widely.
University of Tasmania
Dr Kathleen Williams is the Director of Creative Curriculum and a Senior Lecturer in Media at the University of Tasmania, Australia. She primarily researches the cultural, environmental and industrial impacts of changing media technologies and practices.
The likelihood that climate change may destroy the Great Barrier Reef has been a central motif in Australia’s climate change politics for more than a decade as political ideologies and corporate and environmental activism draw or refute connections between the coal industry and climate change. The media fuel this debate because in this contest, as ever, the news media always do more than simply report the news. Given that the Reef has also been central to the evolution of Australia’s environmental laws since the 1960s, it is not surprising that the Reef is now a leading actor in efforts to test the capacity of our environmental laws to support action on climate change. In this contribution, we examine the news coverage of the Australian Conservation Foundation’s (ACF) 2015 challenge to Adani’s Carmichael coal mine to observe the discursive struggle between the supporters and opponents of the mine. Our analysis of the case shows that while the courts are arenas of material and symbolic contest in the politics of climate change in Australia, public interest environmental litigants struggle both inside and outside the courts to challenge the privileging of mining interests over the public interest.
Chapter 8
Mackay Conservation Group
Peter McCallum is a jack-of-all-trades, having worked as a farm labourer, truck driver, graphic artist and event organiser among other jobs. Peter joined Mackay Conservation Group when he moved to the region in 1993. He is currently the group’s coordinator.
Chapter 9
Griffith University
Kerrie Foxwell-Norton lectures in Journalism, Media and Communication. Her research interests focus upon environmental communication, with a special interest in coastal and marine communities and their environments. Kerrie has specific expertise in community based research and engagement, exploring links between communication and community therein.
She leads the ‘Motivation’ theme within the Griffith Climate Action Beacon, a strategic university wide research initiative. She is Co-Chair of the Environment, Science and Risk Working Group and a member of the Environmental Impact Committee for the International Association of Communication and Media Research. She is also the Co-Chair of the Queensland Chapter for the Australian Coastal Society and Associate Editor (Environment) for Queensland Review.
Monash University
Dr Deb Anderson is a journalist and academic born in Far North Queensland, now based in Melbourne. Her research at Monash University draws from oral history, journalism and ecofeminism to explore the lived experience of extreme weather in an era of politicised knowledge on climate change. She is the author of Endurance: Australian Stories of Drought (CSIRO, 2014).
Anne Leitch is a science communication researcher who began her career with jobs that took her all over the Great Barrier Reef counting crown-of-thorns starfish, recording fish behaviour and identifying reef invertebrates. She now spends her time writing about these things and researching climate change adaption and community resilience to coastal change.
In the late 1970s, Carden Wallace was at the beginning of her lifelong exploration of the Great Barrier Reef — and indeed, reefs all over the world. For Wallace, who is now Emeritus Principal Scientist at Queensland Museum, the beginning of her Reef career coincided with the emergence of both feminist and environmental movements that meant her personal and professional lives would be entwined with a changing social, cultural and political milieu. In this article, we couple the story of Wallace’s personal life and her arrival in coral science to identify the Reef as a gendered space ripe to explore both feminist and conservation politics. The article is part of a broader Women of the Reef project that supports a history of women’s contribution to the care and conservation of the Reef since the 1960s. In amplifying the role of women in the story of the Reef, we find hope in the richness of detail offered by oral history to illuminate the ways discourse on the Reef and its women sits at the intersection of biography, culture, politics and place. In these stories, we recognise women’s participation and leadership as critical to past challenges, and to current and future climate change action. By retelling modern Reef history through the experiences and achievements of women, we can develop new understandings of the Reef that disrupt the existing dominance of patriarchal and Western systems of knowledge and power that have led us to the brink of ecological collapse.
Chapter 10
Bill Wilkie’s first book, The Daintree Blockade, won the Premier’s Award at the Queensland Literary Awards in 2017. His writing has featured in The Saturday Paper, Griffith Review, QWeekend and Ecotone. His next book is about the Cedar Bay drug raids of the 1970s.
Chapter 11
Drawing a Line in the Sand: Bioengineering as Conservation in the Face of Extinction Debt [+–] 169-182
Western Sydney University
Dr Josh Wodak works at the intersection of the Environmental Humanities and Science and Technology Studies. His research addresses the socio-cultural dimensions of the climate crisis and the Anthropocene, with a focus on the ethics and efficacy of conservation through technoscience, including synthetic biology, assisted evolution and climate engineering. He is currently a Senior Research Fellow at the Institute for Culture and Society, Western Sydney University, a Chief Investigator at the ARC Centre for Excellence in Synthetic Biology and an Adjunct Senior Lecturer, School of Biological, Earth, and Environmental Sciences, University of New South Wales.
What conservation could possibly become commensurate with the rates of human-induced biophysical change unfolding at the advent to the Sixth Extinction Event? Any such conservation would require time-critical interventions into both ecosystems and evolution itself, for these interventions would also require domains of risk and ethics that shatter normative understandings of conservation. Yet a line appears to have been drawn in the sand against such experimental conservation. Holding the line will retain conservation practices that are null and void against the extinction debt facing multitudes of species. Crossing the line would invoke scales of bioengineering that appear abhorrent to normative morality. This article explores the question of whether this line in the sand could, and should, be crossed through a detailed case study of current and proposed conservation for endangered Chelonia mydas sea turtles on Raine Island, a small coral cay on the Great Barrier Reef in Australia. Chelonia mydas and Raine Island are presented as synecdoche for conservation across diverse species across the world because turtles are among the most endangered of all reptiles and Raine Island is the largest and most important rookery in the world for this species. With such lines disappearing under the rising seas, the article contemplates the unthinkable questions that our current situation demands we ask, and perhaps even try to answer.
Chapter 12
Leonard Andy is a Djiru Traditional Owner currently living at Mission Beach on his traditional land. He creates a number of unique art pieces including paintings, sculptures and wooden artefacts. His attention to detail is evident in the intricate designs painted on his carved wooden swords, boomerangs, spear throwers and canvases.
Epilogue
Australian Catholic University
Professor Iain Duncan McCalman, AO, FRHistS, FASSA, FAHA, FRSN was born in Malawi, Africa, schooled in Zimbabwe, and earned his BA, MA and PhD in Melbourne and Canberra, Australia. He recently retired from a position as Research Professor of History and Co-Director of the Sydney Environment Institute at the University of Sydney. He has held many Visiting Research Fellowships in Britain and the United States, including at All Souls and Oriel Colleges, Oxford, Princeton,New Jersey, and as a Mellon Visiting Professor at the California Institute of Technology, Pasadena.
Iain is a Fellow and former President of the Australian Academy of the Humanities, and a Fellow of three other Learned Academies in Australia and Britain, and is a Professor Emeritus of the University of Sydney and the Australian National University.